Clear turquoise water beside a sunwashed seawall and a compact pale seafoam waterfront cottage on Cudjoe Key.

What 2026 Sales in Venture Out Say About Paying for Water on Cudjoe Key

November 19, 2026

"Our canals and seawalls were created over 50 years ago, and continuous erosion has taken its toll on the seawalls, which are a key element of our infrastructure." Venture Out of Cudjoe Cay, Inc. wrote that sentence in a February 2025 funding request to the Florida House of Representatives. It is the clearest description available of what a buyer is paying for in this gated community at 701 Spanish Main Drive. Here the houses are close to the same size. The prices follow the water, and the edge of that water is one long stretch of 1970s seawall that every owner shares.

Venture Out has 659 residential condominium units on RV and mobile-home sites. The homes on them are small. A 2-bedroom manufactured home listed on Oct. 9, 2026 measures 748 square feet and asks $329,000. Another 2-bedroom manufactured home, listed Sept. 16, 2026 and marked contingent in its MLS record, measures 828 square feet and asks $799,000. The second home is 80 square feet larger and costs $470,000 more. Square footage can't account for that gap. The rest of this post looks at what does.

The 2026 sales, sorted by what the lot faces

Florida Keys MLS data as of Oct. 15, 2026 lists the Venture Out sales and pendings recorded so far this year. Most of the 2-bedroom homes on that list have a seawall of about 35 feet. What changes from one sale to the next is the water beyond the seawall.

Venture Out unit, 2026 sale Description in the MLS record Price
Unit 214 2 BR, open water, 35' seawall, furnished $870,000
Unit 512 2 BR, 43' seawall, open water views $840,000
Unit 51 2 BR, 35' seawall, ocean views, stilted home $837,000
Unit 47 2 BR, 47' seawall, open water $775,000
Unit 374 2 BR, oceanfront, 35' seawall, furnished $650,000
Unit 510 2 BR, canal front, 35' seawall $525,000
Unit 234 2 BR, canal front, 35' seawall $440,000
Unit 625 2 BR, turnkey $291,000
Unit 457 2 BR, canal front, 35' seawall $200,000

The canal-front rows tell the most. Units 510, 234 and 457 each sold this year with a 35-foot canal seawall, at $525,000, $440,000 and $200,000. Units 214 and 512 have seawalls of about the same length but look out on open water, and they sold for $870,000 and $840,000. In 2026 Venture Out sales, the seawall line in a listing set the price far less than the water the seawall faces and the condition of the home on the lot.

On Cudjoe Key, ocean view, open water and canal are separate price bands, even inside a single gated community. For canal homes outside the gates, see our Cudjoe Key canal-front buyer guide.

The lot sales show how little the house adds

Venture Out also sells bare lots, and the 2026 lot sales show where the value sits. In the same Oct. 15 MLS data, Lot 384, with open water and a 53-foot seawall, sold for $480,000. Lot 574, canal front with an ocean view and a 35-foot seawall, sold for $420,000. Lot 183, canal front with a 35-foot seawall and open water views, sold for $415,000.

So in 2026, an empty lot with open water views sold for more than twice what Unit 457 brought with a 2-bedroom home and a canal seawall. Lots without a water description, such as Lot 317 at $205,000 and Lot 610 at $195,000, sold within a few thousand dollars of the cheapest finished homes.

Asking prices in the Oct. 15 MLS snapshot repeat the pattern. Homes asked from $239,000 for Unit 533, a 1-bedroom with an addition, up to $949,600 for Unit 198, an oceanfront 2-bedroom with a seawall. Lots asked from $255,000 to $514,900, and the top lot ask was for Lot 266 with a 35-foot seawall. Some listings also carry their own labels, such as "ROGO Exempt" on Lot 643 and "Nightly Rentals Allowed" on Lot 69. Those labels belong to the individual lot. Buyers should confirm each one for the specific lot they are considering.

Build quality changes the numbers at the margin. Units 29 and 30 were built in 2024 with 9-foot ceilings and impact-rated windows and doors, and each was asking $649,000 in the October snapshot. Newer construction can move a home up the ladder, but the top of the 2026 sales list belongs to open water.

The seawall belongs to the whole community's ledger

This is the part of a Venture Out purchase that a listing photo doesn't show. In its February 2025 request, the association reported that 445 of its 659 units have water frontage. It said 231 of those units, with 8,085 linear feet of seawall, still needed repair, and that "more areas are going from green to red (danger)." It traced the damage to Hurricane Irma, to seawalls built in the early 1970s, and to weather.

The association described the work as repair and hardening of its coastal and canal seawalls, including some added elevation and erosion mitigation. It estimated that the traditional concrete method "could exceed 12 million." A new technology it was testing would bring the cost to $6.5 million. The request, sponsored by Rep. Jim Mooney, asked the state for $6.5 million of a $6.75 million total, with $250,000 from other funding.

"Venture Out" does not appear in the enacted FY 2025-26 General Appropriations Act, and it does not appear in the FY 2026-27 budget that runs through June 30, 2027. The 8,085-foot figure is the association's own count as of February 2025. Any buyer should ask for the current figure.

That request explains why the open-water premium in the sales table is only part of the price. A buyer paying $870,000 for an open-water unit is buying a view that rests on a seawall the association itself treated as community infrastructure when it sought repair money. A buyer paying $291,000 for a home with no water listed in its description sits behind the same community-wide project, even though the sales table prices each lot's view separately.

What the quarterly assessment covers today

According to the association's FAQ dated April 1, 2026, the current quarterly assessment is $1,560.24 per unit, of which $739.31 goes to reserves and the rest to maintenance. This fall's MLS listings show association fees of $1,540.34 a quarter on Unit 543 and $1,560 on Unit 171. These figures are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm the current ledger and any planned capital projects with the association and your own advisors before you write an offer.

For that assessment, the association's marina page lists dual concrete ramps, a marine ship store, a fuel dock and 24/7 gated security. The association FAQ lists a community pool and hot tub. The community's newest amenity shows how things get done here. Its fish-cleaning area was paid for with donations from owners, the Boat Club, renters and local businesses, and maintenance staff built it.

The same money elsewhere on Cudjoe Key

Venture Out's open-water prices overlap with conventional single-family homes elsewhere on the island. In Cudjoe Key's fall 2026 MLS listings, a 2-bedroom single-family home in Cutthroat Harbor Estates was asking $795,000 after six days on the market. That is within the range of 2026 open-water sales in Venture Out. In Cudjoe Acres, a 3-bedroom single-family listing with no HOA was asking $1,645,000 after 39 days on the market in the same set of listings.

For a Venture Out buyer at the top of the range, the real comparison is between two ways of paying for water. In Venture Out, the price buys a small home on an open-water lot. The marina, ramps, fuel dock and seawall plan are shared across all 659 units, at a set quarterly fee. Outside the gates, a similar price buys a conventional single-family home, and the Cudjoe Acres listing above carries no HOA at all. Which one fits depends on how you plan to use the boat, the home and your time on the island. More on the island's other subdivisions is on our Cudjoe Key neighborhood page.

For the low end of the Venture Out range, the 2026 sales are the clearest guide. A canal-front 2-bedroom with a 35-foot seawall sold for $200,000 this year. That is the lowest entry point to Cudjoe Key water in the MLS data, and the same community seawall project applies to that lot too.

Our brokerage, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Keys Real Estate, has listings in Venture Out this season, including Unit 171 and Unit 123. Before you compare an open-water unit with a canal lot, or either one with a single-family home in Cutthroat Harbor Estates, I'm glad to pull the MLS sales history for the units you're weighing and ask the association about its current seawall plans. Reach out to Key West Sherri, and let's connect about the water you want to buy into on Cudjoe Key.

Experience Seamless Buying & Selling

I am committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, I've got you covered.