November 5, 2026
In 1991, Gary Teplitsky and Olga Manosalvas were buying a little shop called Baby's at 1111 Duval Street, and they settled what it would sell with a coin toss. According to the story Teplitsky told Keys Weekly this September, heads meant coffee and tails meant barbecue. It came up coffee. In 1995 the business moved to MM 15, and it has been the first stop on the Lower Keys stretch of US-1 ever since.
That coin toss explains a lot about how this part of the Keys eats. Between Baypoint and Mangrove Mama's there are only a few places to get food or a drink, and each one covers a different part of the day. If you take them in order, you can go from a 6 a.m. coffee to a 10 p.m. last call without crossing into Key West.
| Window | Place | Where | Hours to know |
|---|---|---|---|
| Early morning | Baby's Coffee | 3180 US Highway 1, MM 15 | Daily, 6 a.m. to 5 p.m. |
| Breakfast onward | The Cafe at Sugarloaf KOA | 251 State Road 939 | 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. |
| Lunch | Mangrove Mama's | 19991 Overseas Hwy., MM 20 | Opens 11 a.m. daily |
| Afternoon happy hour | Mangrove Mama's, then the KOA Pub | MM 20 and State Road 939 | Weekdays 3 to 6 p.m.; daily 4 to 6 p.m. |
| Sunset | Sugarloaf Lodge tiki | MM 17 | Drinks from the marina or South of the Seven |
| Dinner | South of the Seven | Sugarloaf Lodge, MM 17 | Bar opens 4:30 p.m.; dinner Tuesday through Saturday |
| Late | Mangrove Mama's or the KOA Pub | MM 20 and State Road 939 | Up to 10 p.m. on weekends |
Read down the table and the gaps are small. Baby's closes at 5 p.m., half an hour after South of the Seven's bar opens. Mangrove Mama's has been open since 11 that morning. Every slot in the day has at least one place open, and the sections below go through them in order.
Baby's Coffee is open every day from 6 a.m. to 5 p.m. at 3180 US Highway 1, and it has been roasting in the Keys since 1991. Joe Bracciale and Alessandra Torre bought the Baypoint café in 2024, and Teplitsky still roasts for the business. Keys Weekly describes the beans as high-mountain-grown Jamaican coffee.
This fall's news is an addition, not a move. Baby's opened a second shop on Fleming Street in Old Town at the start of September, and the MM 15 original stays where it is. Bracciale told Keys Weekly that the business ships 35,000 bags of coffee a month across the continent, and he described who comes first:
"Our focus is always on the locals. Obviously we're here for the tourists and we love them... But the whole business down here is about taking care of the locals."
If you live on Upper Sugarloaf, Baby's is the morning stop you can reach without heading toward town. The cafe at Sugarloaf KOA opens at 8 a.m. with pastries, coffee, sandwiches and pizza.
Mangrove Mama's, at 19991 Overseas Highway, opens at 11 a.m. every day. It stays open until 9 p.m. Monday through Friday and until 10 p.m. on Saturday and Sunday. Its current menu runs from seafood chowder and conch fritters to local-catch dishes, sandwiches, tacos and specialty pizzas, plus daily specials.
Today's version of the restaurant took shape in late 2023. Keys Weekly reported at the time that Jeff Gagnon, Annie van Aller and Beth Connor had reopened Mangrove Mama's with an outdoor tiki bar and a music stage built on a pontoon boat. The owners also planned a menu that rotates dishes and specials. That stage is the reason MM 20 also covers the late slot in the table above, which is covered further down.
This is the busiest part of the schedule, and the order matters:
On Saturday and Sunday, the KOA Pub is the only one of these with a set happy hour, because the Mangrove Mama's happy hour runs on weekdays.
South of the Seven is the dinner reservation in this stretch. Chef Paul Kapsalis and Kris Kubik opened it at Sugarloaf Lodge in April 2019. The Florida Keys tourism council's profile of Kapsalis lists dishes like whole rosefish with Thai chile sauce, tomahawk steaks, whole soft lobster, fish collars and rum cake. The restaurant serves dinner Tuesday through Saturday and asks guests to call ahead.
The Florida Keys Free Press has reported that Sugarloaf Lodge is listed for sale at $45 million. The same report says South of the Seven leases the Lodge's 5,300-square-foot restaurant space.
The schedule has one weekly gap. South of the Seven doesn't serve dinner on Sunday or Monday, so the two later spots cover those evenings. Mangrove Mama's stays open until 10 p.m. on Sunday and 9 p.m. on Monday. The KOA Pub stays open until 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and 10 p.m. on Friday and Saturday.
The two also cover live music. Mangrove Mama's has live music on Thursday, Friday and Saturday and posts the lineups on its Facebook page. The KOA Pub has a stage of its own, and its Thursday night specials feature tacos. The pub is part of a resort, so call before going for food or drinks alone.
Just past the north end of the stretch, Square Grouper at 22658 Overseas Highway, MM 22.5, and Morning Joint at MM 23 add two more Cudjoe options.
The same few places also host the dated events in this stretch over the next two months:
KOA notes that its event dates and times can change, so check the calendar before you go.
Whether you want a sunset seat at MM 17 or a quiet table for out-of-town guests, Sherri Blasingame can point you to the right stop on this stretch of US-1. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
I am committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, I've got you covered.